Where to Stay on St. John for Every Traveler

Deciding what part of the island to stay on should be an easy decision since St. John is only 9 miles long and 3 miles wide, right? Ultimately, your choice will depend on many preferences and interests and we are here to help. Catered To offers nearly 40 villas spread throughout the island.

Here are some considerations for different areas:

Near Cruz Bay

Perfect for vacationers looking for easy access to various shops, restaurants and nightlife. Many people prefer to settle in just down the street from the ferry dock.

Consider Altagracia and Rhapsody

North Shore

If waking up to views of world-class beaches is your thing, you will be delighted by the North Shore!

Consider Limetree at Peter Bay and Hakuna Matata

Near the East End

For a more secluded experience, you’ll want to get closer to Coral Bay, known as the “quiet” side of St. John. Expect fewer crowds, a laid back attitude and plenty of opportunities for exploring.

Consider Francis Bay Estate and On A Clear Day

South Shore

The South Shore offers a mix of beaches and activities, but its real claim to fame is a front row seat to glorious sunsets!

Consider Latitude and Sunset Beach

Higher Elevation

Whether it’s the island’s highest point on Bordeaux Mountain or sweeping panoramic views, take in the magic of the National Park or the many neighboring islands that are only a stone’s throw away.

Consider Esprit and La Jolla Caribe

If you are a repeat visitor, we encourage you to try something new. We have a villa suitable for every type of traveler so give us a call and let our team help you find the perfect fit!